Pin it
Picture this: my abuela's kitchen filled with the sweet aroma of coconut and rum. That's where I first learned to make authentic Coquito our cherished Puerto Rican holiday drink. Every December I carry on her tradition whipping up this creamy coconut dream that turns ordinary gatherings into unforgettable celebrations. Let me share our family recipe that's been passed down through generations.
A Taste of Puerto Rican Love
My kitchen comes alive when I make Coquito. There's something magical about blending those creamy coconut flavors with warming spices that just feels like a warm hug in a glass. Every time I serve it at holiday parties guests' eyes light up with that first sip. Even my non Puerto Rican friends now request their own bottles weeks before Christmas.
What's in My Cart
- Rum: 1 1½ cups of good quality aged rum. Splurge here trust me it makes all the difference.
- Sweetened Condensed Milk: 1 can for that silky sweetness we all crave.
- Cream of Coconut: Grab Coco Lopez it's what my abuela swears by.
- Coconut Milk: The full fat kind none of that light stuff.
- Evaporated Milk: 1 can to make everything extra luxurious.
- Spices: Fresh nutmeg and cinnamon sticks from my local spice shop.
- Vanilla: Pure extract only in my kitchen.
Pin it
Kitchen Magic Time
- The Secret Infusion
- First things first let those cinnamon sticks swim in rum. The longer they soak the better your Coquito tastes.
- Blend it Up
- Throw all those creamy ingredients in your blender until they're smooth as silk.
- Add the Good Stuff
- Pour in that cinnamon infused rum. Start slow you can always add more.
- Beauty Sleep
- Now comes the hard part waiting. Let it chill overnight the flavors need time to get cozy together.
- Pour with Love
- Give it a good shake then serve it up with a dusting of fresh nutmeg.
Make it Your Own
Some nights I get creative adding a splash of Fireball for extra warmth. My sister swears by her chocolate version with a spoonful of Nutella. Making it for the kids? Skip the rum and use extract instead. Last Christmas I surprised everyone with pumpkin Coquito and now they beg for it every year.
Perfect Pairings
Nothing beats sipping Coquito alongside my slow roasted pernil or crispy sweet maduros. For dessert pair it with tres leches cake pure heaven. I love setting out little bowls of rum soaked raisins for guests to garnish their drinks.
Keep it Fresh
Your Coquito will stay delicious for up to 6 weeks in the fridge though it never lasts that long in my house. Don't worry if you see some separation happening just give it a good shake. The flavors actually get better after a few days.
More Than Just a Drink
Every time I make Coquito I feel connected to my roots. The recipe brings back memories of holiday parties at my abuela's house where aunties would compare their secret recipes. Now my own kids help me measure ingredients and my kitchen fills with the same love and laughter I grew up with.
Share the Love
My favorite holiday tradition is bottling up Coquito for friends. I collect pretty bottles all year round decorate them with ribbons and hand write little recipe cards. Nothing beats seeing their faces light up when I deliver these bottles of liquid joy.
Pin it
Your Coquito Questions
- Storage Tips: Keep it cold and give it a good shake before pouring.
- Kid Friendly Version: Use rum extract it's just as delicious.
- Spice Magic: The longer those cinnamon sticks soak the better.
- Separation Happens: Just shake it up no worries.
- Rum Choices: I love using aged rum but coconut rum works beautifully too.
Bottled Memories
Every batch of Coquito tells a story of family tradition love and celebration. Whether you're sticking to my abuela's classic recipe or creating your own twist you're now part of our beautiful Puerto Rican holiday tradition. Salud!
Frequently Asked Questions
- → How long does coquito last?
- When stored in the refrigerator, coquito stays good for up to 6 weeks. Always keep it chilled and shake well before serving.
- → Can I make coquito without alcohol?
- Yes, you can skip the rum for a non-alcoholic version. The coconut and milk mixture still tastes delicious on its own.
- → Why isn't my coquito thick?
- Coquito needs at least 4 hours in the refrigerator to thicken properly. The cream of coconut and condensed milk will help it reach the right consistency.
- → What type of rum is best?
- White rum is traditional, but dark rum works too. Puerto Rican rum is most authentic, but any good quality rum will work well.
- → Can I freeze coquito?
- While you can freeze coquito, the texture might change slightly when thawed. It's best enjoyed fresh or stored in the refrigerator.