Pin it
My Potato Broccoli Casserole brings pure comfort to any table. I created this recipe while looking for ways to combine our favorite vegetables and now it's become a family treasure. The way creamy potatoes tender broccoli and rich cheese sauce come together creates magic in every bite making weeknight dinners feel special.
Pure Comfort Magic
Something wonderful happens when potatoes broccoli and cheese unite in one cozy dish. Each spoonful brings that perfect balance of creamy comfort and fresh vegetable goodness. I love how this casserole fits any occasion from busy weeknights to holiday tables makes everyone happy.
From My Kitchen to Yours
- Fresh Potatoes: 2½ pounds russets peeled ready for creamy dreams.
- Bright Broccoli: 4 cups cut just right keeps color pop.
- Cream Cheese: 4 ounces soft brings silky smoothness.
- Season Salt: 2 teaspoons makes everything sing.
- Fresh Pepper: ½ teaspoon cracked adds life.
- Rich Half & Half: ½ cup creates dreamy sauce.
- Real Sour Cream: 1½ cups full fat no shortcuts.
- Good Cheese: 1½ cups Colby-Jack freshly shredded.
- Sweet Butter: 5 tablespoons divided with love.
Pin it
Creating Casserole Joy
- Cozy Beginnings
- Warm oven to 375°F butter dish gentle with love.
- Sauce Dreams
- Melt butter cream cheese spices watch them become silk.
- Veggie Love
- Cook potatoes tender add broccoli last keeps color bright.
- Coming Together
- Toss everything gentle spread with care top with cheese dreams.
- Golden Time
- Bake until bubbly golden let rest share while warm.
Make It Your Own
Sometimes I use golden potatoes brings buttery notes. Greek yogurt works beautifully when wanting tang. A pinch of cayenne adds warm spice adventure. Watch that broccoli keeps its pretty green gives nice bite. Let everything settle makes serving neater prettier.
Keeping Comfort Fresh
Leftovers stay happy two days covered well in fridge. Warm gentle in microwave or oven brings back that fresh baked joy. While freezing changes things prepare ahead bake fresh when ready makes everything perfect.
Kitchen Questions Answered
Make ahead dreams come true assemble early bake when ready. Try different cheeses each brings its own magic. Keep vegetables dry prevents swimming sauce. Pairs beautifully with roasted chicken garden salads crusty bread pure dinner happiness.
Lighter Love
Light cream cheese sour cream work just fine. Whole milk brings same comfort fewer calories. Less cheese still tastes wonderful. Small changes keep comfort brings healthier joy to our table.
Pin it
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I make this ahead?
Assemble up to 24 hours ahead but don't bake. Cover and refrigerate, then bake when ready. Add 10-15 minutes to bake time if cold.
- → Why partially cook the broccoli?
Quick-cooking broccoli in potato water brightens color and starts cooking process. It will finish cooking in oven without getting mushy.
- → How do I prevent watery sauce?
Let potatoes steam dry after draining. Using full-fat dairy products and avoiding low-fat substitutes helps sauce stay creamy.
- → Can I use frozen broccoli?
Fresh works best but frozen can be used. Thaw and pat dry first, skip the pre-cooking step.
- → What potatoes work best?
Russet or Yukon Gold potatoes hold shape well. Avoid waxy potatoes as they can make sauce gummy.
Conclusion
A delightful casserole that combines tender potatoes and fresh broccoli in a creamy, cheesy sauce. Perfect for a satisfying family meal that's both nutritious and delicious.